Since Astrid was bought out by Yahoo, I like many others have been looking around for alternatives.
Using Lifehacker and several other similar blogs and turning to colleagues I've found about 3 that try to fill it where Astrid left off.
Wunderlist
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e517d/e517daa12e15fdad907cddc70d4266339cdf4a0d" alt=""
Any do
Workflowy
I've spent far more time in Any do. than any of the other two.
winner
Any do, though I wish it had PDF. I'm really looking forward to the HTML5 client.
Using Lifehacker and several other similar blogs and turning to colleagues I've found about 3 that try to fill it where Astrid left off.
Wunderlist
- Chrome extension is just a launcher for website
- subtasks, but for most things it's overkill.
- skeuomorphism - looks like a page.
- Allows for direct import from Astrid. Making the switch super easy.
- Since there's a web client, sharing and printing is pretty easy.
- Sharing-Integrates with Facebook for task sharing.
Any do
- Clean UI
- voice transcriptions
- no html5 client..yet. There's a huge line for it.
- pulls in actions based on missed calls etc
- Views: Doesn't allow for showing only open tasks on Android App
- No ability to PDF lists
- Chrome app integrates nicely with Gmail without getting in the way
- Daily task review built in, to help make sure the to do list is clean
Workflowy
- More unstructured than the others.
- Great for notetaking
- Can use for creating tickler
- Not sure if there's a mobile app for it for iOS or Android but I would assume so.
I've spent far more time in Any do. than any of the other two.
winner
Any do, though I wish it had PDF. I'm really looking forward to the HTML5 client.